When searching for the best eyeliners, the options can feel overwhelming with so many formulas, finishes, and price points. The tarte Double Take Eyeliner stands out as the best overall, thanks to its versatile dual-pencil and gel design that offers both precision and boldness. For those seeking waterproof performance, the Urban Decay 24/7 Glide-On Waterproof Pencil and the Stila Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner excel in longevity and transfer resistance. However, tradeoffs often involve a balance between ease of application, staying power, and price. Continue reading for a detailed breakdown of the top choices and what makes each one unique.
Key Takeaways
- The best eyeliners combine ease of application with long-lasting wear, but tradeoffs exist between waterproof formulas and ease of removal.
- Gel liners like Stila Stay All Day offer smudge resistance but may require more precise application tools.
- Pencils tend to be more beginner-friendly, while liquid liners deliver sharper, more defined lines—each with different maintenance needs.
- Price doesn’t always correlate with performance; some budget options perform on par with premium brands.
- The most versatile options are those that combine waterproof features with creamy, blendable textures for day-to-night looks.
| eyeliner | Waterproof | Color | Type |
|---|---|---|---|
| tarte Double Take Eyeliner | — | Black | 2-in-1 Pencil and Gel Eyeliner |
| NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Epic I | Yes | Black | Liquid Eyeliner |
| Urban Decay 24/7 Glide-On Wate | — | — | — |
| Maybelline Unstoppable Waterpr | Yes | Onyx (Black) | Mechanical Eyeliner Pencil |
| NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Mechan | — | Onyx, Black | Mechanical Eyeliner |
| e.l.f. H2O Proof Eyeliner Pen | Yes | — | — |
| L’Oreal Paris Voluminous Smold | No | Black | — |
| e.l.f. No Budge Retractable Ey | Yes | Black | Retractable Eyeliner |
| Rimmel London Exaggerate Water | Yes | Blackest Black | — |
| L’Oreal Paris Infallible Grip | Yes | — | Mechanical Gel Eyeliner Pencil |
| Stila Stay All Day® Smudge & S | Yes | — | Gel Eyeliner Pencil |
| Stila Waterproof Liquid Eye Li | Yes | — | Liquid Eye Liner |
| Wonderskin Eyeliner Pencil 144 | Yes | Deep black | — |
| Revlon ColorStay Pencil Waterp | Yes | Black | — |
| Urban Decay Perversion Waterpr | Yes | Black | Liquid Eyeliner |
More Details on Our Top Picks
tarte Double Take Eyeliner – 2-in-1 Pencil and Gel Eyeliner for Bold, All-Day Wear
The tarte Double Take Eyeliner makes an excellent choice for those seeking a versatile, all-in-one solution. Its dual-pencil and gel format offers flexibility that outshines single-purpose liners like the Urban Decay 24/7 Glide-On, which is more specialized but less convenient on the go. The vegan, cruelty-free formula provides a semi-matte finish that stays put without smudging, making it ideal for busy mornings or nights out. Its compact design is perfect for travel, though the limited color options—primarily black—may restrict creativity. The gel component might require sharpening or a brush, adding a small step in application. Compared with liquid liners, it offers easier handling but less precision for intricate lines. Overall, this pick suits those who want convenience without sacrificing quality, as long as they prefer a matte black finish and don’t mind sharpening the pencil.
Pros:- Vegan and cruelty-free, aligning with ethical preferences
- Versatile 2-in-1 pencil and gel format for different looks
- Compact, travel-friendly packaging
Cons:- Limited to black color, restricting variety
- Gel side may require sharpening or a brush for precision
Best for: Anyone who values multi-functionality and travel-friendly design, especially those who wear eyeliner daily and prefer vegan formulas.
Not ideal for: Users who need a wide range of colors or detailed, sharp lines may find this too limited or cumbersome due to sharpening needs.
- Type:2-in-1 Pencil and Gel Eyeliner
- Finish:Matte
- Vegan:Yes
- Cruelty-Free:Yes
- Color:Black
- Application:Easy, lightweight, smudge-free
Our verdict“This eyeliner works best for those seeking a convenient, versatile black liner with a matte finish for everyday or travel use.”
NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Epic Ink Liner, Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner – Black, Vegan Formula
The NYX Epic Ink Liner is designed for those who prioritize sharp, defined lines with lasting power. Its waterproof, matte liquid formula is comparable to the Rimmel Exaggerate Waterproof Eye Definer but offers a more precise, flexible tip that facilitates detailed looks. While it boasts a long-lasting, smudge-proof finish, the liquid consistency might pose a challenge for beginners who prefer a more forgiving application. Multiple coats are often necessary to achieve intense black pigment, which can be time-consuming. Compared with gel or pencil options, it excels in creating crisp lines, though it sacrifices ease of blending. This liner makes the most sense for experienced users or those needing a dependable, waterproof liquid for events or all-day wear, but it might overwhelm newcomers due to its application technique.
Pros:- Long-lasting waterproof, matte finish
- Precise, flexible tip for detailed application
- Vegan and cruelty-free
Cons:- May require multiple coats for full opacity
- Liquid formula can be tricky for beginners to control
Best for: Experienced makeup enthusiasts or anyone needing a highly precise, waterproof liquid eyeliner for long days or special occasions.
Not ideal for: Beginners or those seeking quick, easy application may find this liquid challenging to master due to its consistency and need for multiple coats.
- Type:Liquid Eyeliner
- Finish:Matte
- Color:Black
- Vegan:Yes
- Waterproof:Yes
- Application:Precise, flexible tip for detailed looks
Our verdict“Ideal for experienced users who want a reliable, waterproof liquid liner that delivers sharp, bold lines all day.”
Urban Decay 24/7 Glide-On Waterproof Eyeliner Pencil
The Urban Decay 24/7 Glide-On stands out thanks to its creamy texture and extensive shade selection, making it a favorite for those who want vibrant color in various finishes—matte, shimmer, metallic, or glitter. Its up to 16-hour wear rivals liquid liners like NYX Epic Ink but with less fuss and easier application, especially for those who dislike liquid precision. The hydrating ingredients like vitamin E and jojoba oil help prevent tugging, which is a common issue with pencil liners. However, it requires a sharpener for the most precise application and some shades may lack full pigmentation. This makes it suitable for makeup lovers who value comfort, variety, and long wear without the complexity of liquid liner techniques.
Pros:- Creamy, easy-to-apply texture
- Wide range of shades and finishes
- Hydrating ingredients for comfort
Cons:- Requires sharpening for precise application
- Some shades may be less pigmented
Best for: Makeup aficionados who want a versatile, long-wearing pencil in multiple finishes for everyday or creative looks.
Not ideal for: People who prefer a quick, no-sharpening option or need highly precise lines may find this less convenient or less sharp than liquid liners.
- Finish Options:Matte, shimmer, metallic, glitter
- Wear Time:Up to 16 hours
- Infused Ingredients:Vitamin E, jojoba oil, cottonseed oil
- Vegan:Yes
- Cruelty-Free:Yes
Our verdict“This liner suits those seeking a comfortable, long-lasting pencil with a broad color spectrum and multiple finishes.”
Maybelline Unstoppable Waterproof Mechanical Black Eyeliner Pencil
The Maybelline Unstoppable Mechanical Pencil offers a straightforward, reliable solution for those who want long-lasting, bold black lines with minimal effort. Its mechanical design means no sharpening is needed, a feature that appeals to users who dislike the maintenance of traditional pencils. With up to 24-hour waterproof wear, it outperforms many standard pencils, making it ideal for active days or humid environments. The self-sharpening tip ensures consistent application, but the limited color options—primarily black—may restrict creative choices. While its creamy, smudge-resistant formula is easy to apply, some users might find that it requires layering for very intense looks, and sharpening could be problematic if the mechanism fails. It’s perfect for those who prioritize durability and ease of use over variety.
Pros:- Waterproof and smudge-resistant for all-day wear
- Self-sharpening tip for consistent application
- Long-lasting, up to 24 hours
Cons:- Limited color options, mainly black
- Potential difficulty if the mechanism jams or fails
Best for: Individuals seeking a durable, easy-to-apply black pencil that lasts all day without smudging, especially in humid or active conditions.
Not ideal for: Those who prefer a wide color range or detailed, precise lines that require a sharper tip might find this mechanical pencil less versatile.
- Type:Mechanical Eyeliner Pencil
- Waterproof:Yes
- Smudge Resistant:Yes
- Wear Duration:Up to 24 hours
- Color:Onyx (Black)
Our verdict“This eyeliner is perfect for users who want a fuss-free, long-lasting black pencil that withstands humidity and activity without smudging.”
NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Mechanical Eye Pencil, Vivid Rich Mechanical, Creamy Retractable Eyeliner – Always Onyx, Black
The NYX Mechanical Eye Pencil combines ease of use with intense pigment, making it a strong contender for those who dislike sharpening but want bold, long-lasting black lines. Its twist-up design ensures quick application, rivaling the Revlon ColorStay Pencil in convenience while offering richer color payoff. Its creamy formula glides on smoothly, resisting smudging throughout the day, even in heat and humidity. However, achieving very intense or smoky looks may require multiple layers, and the limited color options restrict creative flexibility. Compared to the Maybelline Unstoppable, it provides a more pigmented, fuss-free experience, especially suited for those who want vibrant, all-day black eyeliner without the hassle of sharpening or touch-ups.
Pros:- Easy twist-up design for quick application
- Long-lasting, smudge-proof formula
- Rich, intense black pigment
Cons:- Limited color options in the lineup
- May need multiple layers for smoky or bold looks
Best for: Users who want a simple, long-lasting, high-pigment eyeliner with minimal maintenance, especially for daily wear in warm conditions.
Not ideal for: People seeking a variety of colors or very precise lines may find this less suitable due to its focus on ease and broad pigment rather than precision tools.
- Type:Mechanical Eyeliner
- Color:Onyx, Black
- Features:Retractable, Smudge-proof, Long-lasting
- Finish:Creamy
Our verdict“This eyeliner is an excellent choice for those wanting effortless, vibrant black lines that last all day with minimal fuss.”
e.l.f. H2O Proof Eyeliner Pen, Felt Tip, Waterproof, Long-Lasting, Jet Black
This waterproof liquid eyeliner stands out for its precise felt tip that allows for detailed, sharp lines, making it perfect for creating defined looks. Compared with the e.l.f. No Budge Retractable Eyeliner, it offers a more controlled application, especially for intricate designs. Its long-lasting, smudge-proof formula ensures your eye makeup stays put all day without touch-ups, though the small 0.02 Fl Oz volume means frequent reapplication if you want intense black. The vegan and cruelty-free ingredients add to its appeal for ethical shoppers. However, it may require multiple coats to achieve a deep black finish, which could be inconvenient for quick routines. Best for users who prioritize precision and lasting power in a waterproof pen.
Pros:- Precise felt tip for detailed application
- Long-lasting, smudge-proof formula
- Vegan and cruelty-free ingredients
Cons:- Small volume size may require frequent repurchasing
- May need multiple coats for intense black color
Best for: Makeup enthusiasts who need a reliable, sharp eyeliner for detailed work and long wear
Not ideal for: Beginners who prefer larger applicators or are concerned about needing multiple coats for full opacity
- Volume:0.02 Fl Oz
- Waterproof:Yes
- Vegan:Yes
- Cruelty-Free:Yes
Our verdict“A top choice for those seeking precise, waterproof eyeliner with all-day wear, despite small size limitations.”
L’Oreal Paris Voluminous Smoldering Eyeliner, Black, 0.056 Oz, 1 Count
This kajal-style eyeliner delivers rich, intense black pigment with a smooth glide, making it well-suited for both everyday subtle lines and bold, smoky eyes. Compared with the e.l.f. H2O Proof Eyeliner Pen, it offers a softer, more forgiving application that’s easier for beginners to master. Its versatility means it pairs well with various makeup styles, but it’s less waterproof than liquid options, so smudging can occur if not set properly. Limited to only black, it doesn’t offer color options for more creative looks. The formula’s creamy texture enables quick, effortless application, though it might require setting with powder or shadow to prevent smudging. Ideal for users wanting a reliable, versatile pencil for daily wear or dramatic effects.
Pros:- Rich, intense black color for dramatic effects
- Glides effortlessly for quick application
- Suitable for creating a range of looks from subtle to bold
Cons:- Can smudge if not properly set or sealed
- Limited to a single color (black)
Best for: Makeup users who want a flexible eyeliner that works for both casual and dramatic styles
Not ideal for: Those seeking a highly waterproof or long-lasting liner for all-day, waterproof needs
- Brand:L’Oreal Paris
- Color:Black
- Size:0.056 Oz
- Waterproof:No
Our verdict“Best suited for those who want a versatile, easy-glide eyeliner for daily or occasional bold looks, accepting potential smudging without setting.”
e.l.f. No Budge Retractable Eyeliner, Creamy, Waterproof, Vegan & Cruelty-Free, Black
The e.l.f. No Budge Retractable Eyeliner excels in delivering waterproof, ultra-pigmented color that lasts through sweat, tears, and humidity. Its creamy texture allows for smooth, effortless application, making it ideal for creating bold lines or lining the waterline. Compared with the Rimmel London Exaggerate Waterproof Eye Definer, it offers a softer, more comfortable glide but may require sharpening, which can be less convenient. Its retractable design makes it portable and less messy, yet the limited color range (primarily black) might restrict creative options. It’s a smart pick for those who want a fuss-free, cruelty-free product with staying power, though precision can be slightly compromised if sharpening isn’t done carefully. Perfect for users who need a waterproof, easy-to-apply pencil that won’t fade or smudge.
Pros:- Waterproof and long-lasting performance
- Creamy texture for easy application
- Vegan and cruelty-free ingredients
Cons:- Requires sharpening for precise application
- Limited color selection
Best for: Consumers seeking a waterproof, creamy pencil for all-day wear and waterline use
Not ideal for: Users who prefer a wide variety of shades or dislike sharpening their pencil regularly
- Type:Retractable Eyeliner
- Waterproof:Yes
- Pigmentation:Ultra-Pigmented
- Color:Black
Our verdict“Ideal for those needing a waterproof, creamy pencil that offers fuss-free, all-day wear, with the tradeoff of needing regular sharpening.”
Rimmel London Exaggerate Waterproof Eye Definer Eyeliner, Blackest Black, 0.01oz
This waterproof eyeliner offers a bold, highly pigmented black with a convenient built-in smudger and sharpener, making it versatile for both sharp lines and smoky effects. Compared with the L’Oreal Infallible Grip Gel Eyeliner, it’s less long-wearing at around 10 hours but excels in quick touch-ups and precise detailing. Its small size means it’s easy to carry, but frequent reapplication may be necessary for full-day wear. The included smudger helps create softer looks, although it can be difficult to control for very fine lines. Its waterproof formula resists smudging and fading, making it suitable for humid conditions. However, removal can be challenging, especially for those with sensitive eyes. This pick makes the most sense for users who need a compact, multi-functional eyeliner for both defined and smudged looks.
Pros:- Highly pigmented for bold color
- Includes built-in smudger and sharpener
- Waterproof and resistant to smudging
Cons:- Small size may require frequent reapplication
- Difficult to remove for sensitive eyes
Best for: People who want a portable, multi-use eyeliner with a built-in smudger for versatile looks
Not ideal for: Those seeking a long-lasting, all-day waterproof liner beyond 10 hours or with a larger size for frequent use
- Color:Blackest Black
- Size:0.01oz
- Waterproof:Yes
- Features:Built-in smudger and sharpener
Our verdict“Best for users looking for a compact, multi-purpose eyeliner capable of both precise and smoky styles, accepting the shorter wear time and small size.”
L’Oreal Paris Infallible Grip Mechanical Gel Eyeliner Pencil, Waterproof, Smudge-Resistant, 36HR Wear, Intense Black, 0.01 Oz
This mechanical gel eyeliner pencil provides an impressive 36 hours of waterproof, smudge-resistant wear, making it ideal for all-day events or humid environments. Its smooth application, combined with a built-in blending tip, allows for versatile looks ranging from sharp lines to soft smudges. Compared with the Rimmel London Exaggerate Waterproof Eye Definer, it offers significantly longer wear and a more flexible application process. Its gentle formula is suitable for sensitive eyes, but the small 0.01 Oz size means frequent repurchasing for extensive use. While the inclusion of a blending tip enhances versatility, some users might find the pencil’s small size inconvenient for larger areas. This pick is best for those needing extreme longevity and smudge resistance in a portable, mechanical format.
Pros:- Impressive 36-hour waterproof, smudge-proof wear
- Includes a blending tip for versatile application
- Suitable for sensitive eyes
Cons:- Small size may result in frequent replacement
- Limited shade options in this size
Best for: Individuals seeking a waterproof, long-lasting eyeliner that can transition from precise lines to smoky looks with ease
Not ideal for: Casual users who prefer larger, more economical pencils for everyday use or those not needing 36-hour wear
- Type:Mechanical Gel Eyeliner Pencil
- Waterproof:Yes
- Smudge-Resistant:Yes
- Wear Duration:Up to 36 hours
Our verdict“Perfect for users who prioritize extreme longevity and versatility in a portable gel-style pencil, accepting frequent repurchases due to small size.”
Stila Stay All Day® Smudge & Set Waterproof Gel Liner
This gel liner stands out for its dual functionality as both a traditional eyeliner and a smudged eyeshadow, making it ideal for creating a variety of looks. Compared with liquid liners like the Urban Decay Perversion, it offers easier blending for softer finishes but sacrifices some precision. Its waterproof formula lasts up to 12 hours, making it reliable for all-day wear, yet it demands careful closing to prevent drying out. The retractable design adds convenience, though it can smudge if not blended quickly. Limited shade info might be a drawback for those seeking more color options. Overall, this pick makes the most sense for users who value versatility and ease of blending in a long-lasting formula.
Pros:- Versatile as both eyeliner and eyeshadow
- Long-lasting waterproof formula
- Easy to apply and blend with retractable design
Cons:- Requires careful closing to prevent drying out
- May smudge if not blended quickly
Best for: Makeup enthusiasts who want a multi-use liner that can double as eyeshadow and last through long days
Not ideal for: Precision-oriented users who prefer a fine, waterproof liquid liner for detailed winged looks
- Type:Gel Eyeliner Pencil
- Waterproof:Yes
- Wear Duration:12 hours
- Application:Waterline-safe, smudgable, retractable
Our verdict“This gel liner is perfect for those seeking a versatile, long-lasting option that can adapt to different eye makeup styles.”
Stila Waterproof Liquid Eye Liner, Stay All Day Makeup with Fine Brush Tip, Smudge-Proof & Transfer-Resistant
This liquid eyeliner excels for precise, sharp lines thanks to its fine brush tip, making it ideal for detailed winged looks. Compared with the Urban Decay Perversion, its fine tip offers more control, although it may require a steadier hand and some practice to master perfect lines. Its satin finish provides a sophisticated look, and the waterproof, transfer-resistant formula ensures all-day wear. However, it can be challenging to remove and may require gentle makeup remover. Its long-lasting nature makes it suitable for users who prioritize durability over ease of application. This liner makes the most sense for those who want professional-looking, precise lines without sacrificing longevity.
Pros:- Precise application with fine brush tip
- Long-lasting, smudge-proof, transfer-resistant
- Elegant satin finish
Cons:- Requires practice for perfect lines
- Application technique may need refinement
Best for: Makeup artists or enthusiasts aiming for sharp, precise eyeliner that lasts all day
Not ideal for: Beginners or those who prefer a quick, smudge-friendly application for casual looks
- Type:Liquid Eye Liner
- Finish:Satin
- Waterproof:Yes
- Application:Fine Brush Tip
- Country of Origin:USA
Our verdict“This liquid liner is ideal for users who prioritize precision and long wear, even if it takes some practice to perfect application.”
Wonderskin Eyeliner Pencil 1440 Longwear Waterproof & Smudge-Proof
The Wonderskin 1440 pencil delivers 24-hour, vibrant black color with a smudge-proof, transfer-proof finish, making it a standout for all-day wear. Compared to Revlon ColorStay Pencil, its high pigmentation and long-lasting formula offer a more intense black and superior staying power. Its cruelty-free and vegan composition appeal to ethical buyers, while TruGlide Technology ensures smooth application. The main tradeoff is that it requires sharpening for fine lines, and removal can be more difficult without makeup remover. If you want a highly pigmented, waterproof pencil that stays put, this product makes the most sense for dedicated eyeliner users who prioritize durability and color intensity.
Pros:- Long-lasting 24-hour wear
- Vibrant, high-intensity black color
- Vegan and cruelty-free formula
Cons:- Requires sharpening for fine lines
- Difficult to remove without proper makeup remover
Best for: Eyeliner users who need a 24-hour, transfer-proof pencil with vibrant black color
Not ideal for: Casual users or those preferring a retractable pencil for quick, everyday application
- Waterproof:Yes
- Long-lasting:24 hours
- Color:Deep black
- Application:Eyeliner and eyeshadow
- Vegan:Yes
- Cruelty-Free:Yes
Our verdict“This pencil is suited for those seeking a highly pigmented, all-day waterproof eyeliner with strong staying power.”
Revlon ColorStay Pencil Waterproof Eyeliner, 201 Black, 0.01 oz
The Revlon ColorStay Pencil offers reliable, long-lasting waterproof performance in a compact size, making it a practical choice for everyday wear. Its easy glide formula and built-in sharpener and smudger add to user convenience, especially for those who want a straightforward application. Compared with Wonderskin’s 1440 pencil, it may not deliver as intense a black but compensates with ease of use and versatility, suitable for both waterline and lash line. The small size means more frequent reapplication for heavy users, and the limited shade options are a drawback. This pick makes the most sense for users seeking a dependable, all-day waterproof pencil with handy features for quick touch-ups.
Pros:- Long-lasting and waterproof for all-day wear
- Includes built-in sharpener and smudger
- Suitable for waterline and lash line
Cons:- Small size may require frequent reapplication
- Limited shade options in this listing
Best for: Casual makeup users or those who want a reliable, easy-to-use waterproof pencil with handy tools
Not ideal for: Pro makeup artists or users seeking vibrant, ultra-pigmented shades in a large size
- Color:Black
- Size:0.01 oz
- Finish:Matte and shimmer
- Waterproof:Yes
- Long-lasting:Up to 24 hours
- Includes:Built-in sharpener, smudger
Our verdict“This pencil is perfect for everyday users who want a dependable, compact, waterproof eyeliner with handy features.”
Urban Decay Perversion Waterproof Fine Point Eye Pen – Black Liquid Liner
This liquid eyeliner is designed for creating sharp, winged, or cat-eye looks thanks to its ultra-fine brush tip. Compared with the Stila liquid liner, it offers a more flexible, semi-matte finish that’s easy to build up for dramatic effects. Its waterproof, long-lasting formula resists smudging and transfer, making it suitable for all-day wear. The main challenge is that achieving perfect wings may require some practice, especially for beginners unfamiliar with fine brushes. Its black color keeps the look classic and versatile, though limited in shade options. Overall, this liner makes the most sense for users confident in their application skills who want a long-wearing, precise liquid liner for statement looks.
Pros:- Ultra-fine brush tip for precise application
- Long-lasting, waterproof formula
- Cruelty-free and paraben-free
Cons:- Requires practice for perfect wings
- Limited to black shade
Best for: Makeup lovers aiming for precise, long-lasting winged or cat-eye looks
Not ideal for: Absolute beginners or casual users who prefer quick, smudge-friendly liners for everyday wear
- Type:Liquid Eyeliner
- Color:Black
- Finish:Semi-Matte
- Waterproof:Yes
- Cruelty-Free:Yes
- Paraben-Free:Yes
Our verdict“This liquid eyeliner is best suited for those comfortable with fine application and seeking sharp, durable winged looks.”
How We Picked
Products were evaluated based on performance, longevity, ease of use, build quality, and value. We prioritized eyeliners that delivered consistent color payoff, resistance to smudging or transfer, and ease of application for different skill levels. Our ranking balances premium features with affordability, ensuring options suit a range of budgets. Consideration was also given to formulas—waterproof, gel, liquid, or pencil—and how well they cater to various makeup styles and user needs. This approach helps identify the most reliable, versatile, and user-friendly eyeliners on the market today.| eyeliner | Color | Waterproof |
|---|---|---|
| tarte Double Take Eyeliner | Black | — |
| NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Epic I | Black | Yes |
| Urban Decay 24/7 Glide-On Wate | — | — |
| Maybelline Unstoppable Waterpr | Onyx (Black) | Yes |
| NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Mechan | Onyx, Black | — |
| e.l.f. H2O Proof Eyeliner Pen | — | Yes |
| L’Oreal Paris Voluminous Smold | Black | No |
| e.l.f. No Budge Retractable Ey | Black | Yes |
| Rimmel London Exaggerate Water | Blackest Black | Yes |
| L’Oreal Paris Infallible Grip | — | Yes |
| Stila Stay All Day® Smudge & S | — | Yes |
| Stila Waterproof Liquid Eye Li | — | Yes |
| Wonderskin Eyeliner Pencil 144 | Deep black | Yes |
| Revlon ColorStay Pencil Waterp | Black | Yes |
| Urban Decay Perversion Waterpr | Black | Yes |
Factors to Consider When Choosing Best Eyeliners
Choosing the best eyeliner depends on your specific makeup routine and preferences. Beyond color and finish, consider how easy the product is to apply, its longevity, and whether it suits your eye shape and skin type. Understanding these factors can help you avoid common pitfalls like smudging or difficulty removing stubborn formulas. A well-chosen eyeliner enhances your look without frustration, so balancing performance with your skill level and daily habits is key.Application Ease and Control
Pick a formula that matches your comfort level—pencils are generally easier for beginners, offering more control and less mess, while liquid liners require a steadier hand but provide sharper lines. Gel liners strike a balance, especially when used with a brush. Consider your experience and how often you’ll apply eyeliner; a product that feels intuitive to use can make daily routines more enjoyable and less frustrating.
Longevity and Waterproof Qualities
Longevity is vital if you want your eyeliner to last through long days or workouts. Waterproof formulas, like those from Urban Decay or Stila, resist smudging and transfer, but they often require special removers. Non-waterproof options may be easier to remove but might need touch-ups. Think about your lifestyle and environment when selecting a formula—don’t compromise on wear if you need all-day staying power.
Formula and Finish
The finish—matte, satin, or glossy—affects the overall look and suitability for different occasions. Matte liners tend to be more versatile and less prone to smudging, while glossy or shimmer finishes can add dramatic effects. Gel and liquid formulas often offer more intense pigmentation, but they may require more skill to apply perfectly. Choose a finish that aligns with your style and comfort level.
Price and Value
High price doesn’t always guarantee better performance, but investing in a quality eyeliner can pay off with improved application and durability. Budget options like e.l.f. or Revlon often provide surprisingly good results, especially for everyday wear. However, premium brands may offer more nuanced formulas, longer wear, or more sophisticated applicators. Weigh your budget against your needs and how much you’re willing to invest in your makeup routine.
Additional Features and Considerations
Look for features like precise tip design, built-in sharpeners, or retractable pencils that suit your makeup style. Some products also come with dual-ended options for versatility. Additionally, consider skin sensitivities—fragrance-free or cruelty-free formulas are available for sensitive skin. Being aware of these extras can help you find an eyeliner that truly complements your makeup habits and values.
Frequently Asked Questions
How do I choose between pencil, gel, and liquid eyeliners?
The choice depends on your skill level and desired look. Pencils are most beginner-friendly, offering control and easy blending, ideal for subtle or smoky styles. Gel liners provide a smooth, creamy texture that works well for both precise lines and softer looks, especially when applied with a brush. Liquid liners are best for sharp, defined lines and dramatic styles but require a steadier hand and more practice. Matching the formula to your comfort and look preferences will yield the best results.
Are waterproof eyeliners worth the extra effort to remove?
Waterproof eyeliners offer superior resistance to smudging, water, and oil, making them ideal for long days or humid environments. However, they often require special removers or more effort to take off completely, which can sometimes irritate sensitive skin. If you have busy mornings or outdoor activities, investing in a good waterproof formula can save you from touch-ups. Otherwise, non-waterproof options are usually easier to remove and more gentle on the skin.
How long should a good eyeliner last before needing replacement?
The lifespan varies depending on the formula and frequency of use. Pencils typically last several months with daily use, especially if sharpened regularly. Liquids and gels, once opened, are often best used within 3-6 months to prevent bacteria buildup and drying out. For those with sensitive eyes or prone to infections, replacing eyeliners more frequently is a wise practice. Proper storage and hygiene can extend the usability of your products.
Can I wear eyeliner if I have sensitive eyes or contact lenses?
Yes, but choosing the right product is key. Look for eyeliners labeled as hypoallergenic, fragrance-free, or ophthalmologist-tested. Gel and pencil formulas tend to be gentler on sensitive eyes, especially if they are designed for contact lens wearers. Avoid waterproof formulas unless necessary, as they can be more difficult to remove and may cause irritation if not removed thoroughly. Testing new products on a small area first can help prevent adverse reactions.
What’s the best way to fix mistakes or smudges during application?
For quick fixes, keep a cotton swab or a clean brush handy. If you make a mistake, gently remove excess product with a cotton swab dipped in makeup remover or use a concealer brush to clean up edges. For smudges, allowing the liner to set briefly before correcting can prevent spreading. Using a waterproof formula initially can help minimize smudging, but precise correction tools are essential to maintain a clean look.
Conclusion
For those seeking the ultimate all-around performer, the tarte Double Take Eyeliner offers outstanding versatility for everyday and bold looks. Budget-conscious shoppers will appreciate the performance of options like e.l.f. No Budge or Revlon ColorStay, which deliver solid results without breaking the bank. Beginners should lean toward pencils or gel formulas for their forgiving application, while experienced users aiming for sharp, dramatic lines might prefer liquid liners like Stila Stay All Day or Urban Decay Perversion. For special occasions or long-wear needs, investing in waterproof, smudge-proof options ensures your look stays flawless from morning to night.
